The Tide and the Waves

Phillips Brooks

Brooks preaches on the words of Jesus to the disciples who had continued with Him in His temptations. Using the picture of the incoming tide that carries the breaking waves, he shows that a life consecrated to God can be truly succeeding even while many single efforts fail, as Christ's own work did. He warns that sin is always a loss, yet assures the struggling believer that failure is not final while the heart holds fast to God, and that Christ gives success beneath our failures.

"Ye are they which have continued with Me in My temptations. And I appoint unto you a kingdom, as My Father hath appointed unto Me."—Luke xxii. 28, 29.

There are many texts in the Bible from which I might easily start in saying what I especially want to say to you to-day. I take this one because it will connect our study with the history of Christ. It was near the end of His ministry. He was rejoicing in its great success. Behold, He and His disciples were to have a kingdom where they were to reign like kings. But as He thinks of this successful close of His great work His mind runs back over the days when it had seemed as if it never would succeed. They who are to share His kingdom are also they who have been with Him "in His temptations." The end could not be reached without recalling the memory of all the dark stages of the journey. He could not stand in the glory of success without remembering how He had passed through clouds of failure. The days when the Pharisees had insulted Him, when the people had turned deaf ears to His teachings, when even His own disciples had staggered in their faith and hesitated whether they would not leave Him—all these days came back to His remembrance, as to the recollection of many a man the days of his failure have seemed to start into life and reality again just as he was stretching out his...

It is this subject which I wish to speak about to-day—the relation between success and the failures which precede it. What have the failures to do with the success? Evidently there are two possible ideas regarding their relationship. One idea would make the failures and the success to be quite separate from each other. It would suppose that a man went on failing and failing and failing for a long time, until at last his circumstances changed and everything was altered. Some lucky accident sent the wind round the other way, and then the ship, which had been struggling in the face of the gale and losing ground all the time, was caught by the new breeze and carried on triumphantly into its port. The other idea believes that the success which shows itself at last cannot possibly be the sudden thing which it appears to be. It must have been present, gradually working itself out underneath the failures, all the time. The failures must have been borne upon its bosom, and even in some degree created by the local and temporary reactions of the same force which made the great success. There is a verse of one of the subtlest and truest of the English poets of our time which expresses so...

"For while the tired waves, vainly breaking, Seem here no painful inch to gain, Far back, through creeks and inlets making, Comes silent, flooding in, the main."

You see the picture which is in those words—a stretch of sea-shore beach, with the waves breaking in upon it, but every wave a failure; every wave bursting with a little petulant hiss upon the shore, and falling back disappointed into the great body of the sea behind it; every wave a failure, but all the while the great sea itself, far out behind the sea-shore waves, lifted with a mighty movement and rolling itself irresistibly in upon the shore.

"Through creeks and inlets making, Comes silent, flooding in, the main."

The noisy waves are failures, but the great silent tide is a success. The waves are borne upon the bosom of the tide; they share its motion; nay, the failure of each of them in some degree is a reaction of the tide's motion as it is cast back from the beach. But all the time the tide is succeeding while the waves are failing. The failures are carried on the bosom of a success which is present underneath them all the time. This is the idea of the relation of failures and success to each other which is in the verse of Clough. If we drew a sea-picture of the other idea it would not be, like this, a picture of the tide behind and under the waves. It would be a picture of the turning tide, of the flow following upon the ebb, of a tide which had fallen into failure followed by another tide which brought success. This would be the fitting picture of success and failure separate from each other, and one only coming into life after the other had died and passed away.

I hope that I do not obscure with metaphors what I want to make very plain indeed. Let us turn back and see exactly what our metaphors mean when we apply them to the life of Jesus, of which I began to speak. There had been a day, two years before, when Jesus was preaching at Capernaum; and when His sermon was finished it is written that "many of His disciples went back, and walked no more with Him." It was the darkest period of His ministry. It was the time when it most seemed as if His Gospel was going to be left on one side, and He was going to do no mighty work. And now what shall we say about that time in its relation to the other time, recorded in the chapter from which I take my text, when He sat with His disciples at the table of the Passover and calmly shared with them the kingdom which His Father had bestowed on Him? Was it simply that between these two times something had happened which had made a change in the fortunes of the Gospel, so that what once was failing afterward began to succeed? Was it not, far more truly, that the Gospel was always succeeding from the first, and that what seemed its temporary failures had always been backed by and borne upon a great...

Now it does seem to me to be of very great importance that you and I, my friends, men and women who are sure to fail in hundreds and hundreds of the best struggles of our lives—nay, who are sure to fail in some large degree in all the special struggles which we ever make—and yet who know that life would be intolerable unless we kept the hope of some success which we should ultimately win, should have and always keep this higher view of the relations of success and failure which we have said must have been in Jesus. Here are you, for instance, wrestling with your special sin, with that old enemy whom you carry about with you, bound up in the selfsame heart with all your best aspirations and desires. Every special effort that you make to conquer that sin fails. Every time you try to be true you are half false. Every time you try to be spiritual the carnality about you beats you back. Every time you set up the white banner of purity the dark clouds of lust gather around it and it is well-nigh lost. Do you not know the picture?—the weary sense of being beaten; the old familiar disappointment that comes back at the close of the day, when you let your hands drop and say, "Well, once...

I am sure that I speak to the consciousness of some of you, my friends, when I speak thus. Do you not know what it is to be failing every day, and yet to be sure—humbly but deeply sure—that your life is, as a whole, in its great movement and meaning, not failing, but succeeding? You want to do that best work that a man can do—to make life brighter and nobler for your fellow-men. Not a day passes in which you do not somehow try to do that blessed work; but every time you turn away after one of those attempts to give sympathy or inspiration to your brethren, how your heart sinks, so cold and so ignoble are the words which you meant to be so generous and warm! And yet all the while you know that the whole life does not fail. Still there is the purpose! It does not die. It is not given up. It presses forward, wounded and bleeding, but more and more determined every day. Every day it grows clearer and clearer to you that without that wish and hope and resolution life would not be worth living. You want to be absolutely true. But see! the account which you gave of yourself yesterday told only half the truth. The day before you could not bring yourself squarely to face the fact. Last...

I hear men say, "Oh, it is not so bad for me to drink, to steal, to lie, for I am not a Christian, I make no profession, I have never pledged myself nor undertaken to live a holy life." They are all wrong. They are failing from top to bottom—failing all the way down. They are succeeding neither in the special acts nor in the general purpose of their lives. The poor stumbling saint who through a thousand falls and defeats keeps still the consecration of his life, and will be God's through everything, melancholy enough his broken and unworthy life may be; but it is better, even so, than if he cast his consecration off; better, even so, than his brother's life beside him, who makes no consecration of his life and sins in wanton freedom and feels no self-rebuke.

I know that I am treading here on dangerous ground. I know that I am dealing with ideas which men have terribly perverted and misused. But the ground is not to be abandoned because it is dangerous; the ideas are not to be denied because of their misuse. This truth which I am preaching is no conceited antinomianism making believe that a man's sins are no sins for him if only his heart is pious and his general intentions good. Nor is it any silly and mischievous doctrine about evil being only "good in the making"—a necessary stage in every man's progression to the purer life. No! Both of these ideas are bad. Sin is sin whoever does it. Sin is sin however out of its poisonous heart may come some blessed medicine of penitence and watchfulness for the soul that does it. Both of these doctrines are destructive. Sin is always bad—always a loss. The wave that seems to fail does fail. Only he who makes that truth the only truth of life and sees no other truth is leaving out the deepest truth, the truth in which redemption lies. Not in the leaves, but in the root, lives the tree's life. Not in the act, but in the heart, are the issues of life and death; and failure never is total and...

It would be interesting, if we had time, to see at length how the principle of which we are speaking applies to faith as well as conduct. Many and many an attempt of yours to believe in divine things seems a failure. Perhaps all evidence that you can find for their existence seems inconclusive and unsatisfactory. Perhaps, allowing fully their existence, every effort to get hold of them, to fix them close to your life with any such grasp as could properly be called faith, appears a failure. How many such discouragements there are! How many special efforts to believe are just exactly like the reaching up of waves on to the shore, a struggle upward, a wild, convulsive, desperate reach forward, and then a falling back again into the bosom of the great ocean out of which the ambitious and enterprising wave ventured to spring! But yet we know that is not all the story. That great bosom of the sea itself is moving shoreward, and the next ambitious, enterprising wave which tries its strength upon the shore will start from a sea-line more advanced, and will make a little higher record of itself upon the sand, before it too falls away—will fail a little farther on. Is there not something...

I am sure that it must help many of us if we can see how our truth is true, also, with regard to the matter of happiness and sorrow. There is a happiness so deep, a furnishing of the nature so profoundly with the conditions of joy, that it may bear upon its breast a hundred sorrows and yet be happy still. Alas if it were not so! Alas if the perpetual presence of disappointed hopes and broken plans and severed ties were all; if underneath them all it were not possible for a soul to carry in itself so true and rich a peace and contentment in the divinest things that it should know not merely that it was going to be happy some day or other, when the great change should come, but that it was happy now with a happiness that nothing could disturb!

And yet once more, I find in our truth of the double fact of life, the fact of deeper condition and the superficial phenomena, the fact of the tide and the wave in all existence—I find in this the real key to the state and the prospects of the world at large. The world is growing better—I know it. A great unceasing movement toward truth and goodness is carrying slowly forward ever the character of this great, mighty, mysterious humanity. How slow it is, but oh, how real it is, the study of the ages tells. And yet behold how the good causes fail. Behold how selfishness comes in to paralyze each great endeavor for the good of man. Alas for him who only sees this surface fact; who does not feel beneath it all the heave and movement of the whole race forward toward goodness, toward God! To him who hears at once the tumult of moral failures all around him and the steady progress of the great moral success beneath him—to him the world becomes solemn and beautiful, pathetic and full of hope. For him despairing pessimism and silly optimism both become impossible. A divine optimism, which, while it dares not say, "Whatever is is best," devoutly says, "The best is strongest and shall...

"Ye must be born again," said Jesus. I ponder these divine words of His, and ever more and more they seem to me immeasurably deep. There is no end to them. To think of them is like gazing into endless space. But one great truth which they assuredly contain is this: that life for any man is not complete until a deeper and a higher life is put beneath and over the mere life of action, into which the soul can perpetually retreat, and on whose breast the life of action can be buoyantly upborne. There are men who the world thinks are always failing who are themselves conscious of a success which is a truer truth to them than all their failures. They are the men who have been born again, and who carry the new life underneath the old life all the while. The Master of that new life is Christ. The soul worried and torn with disappointments, haunted by the taunts of fellow-souls which tell it it has failed, suspicious of itself, yet keeping still its faithfulness and consecration, goes to Him, to Christ, and lo! it finds a new fact there. Below its failures He has for it success. Through all its deaths He brings out for it, as He brought out for Himself, life! "I too," He says, "seemed to...

Whatever failures He may have for us to pass through first, may He bring us all at last to that success in Him.

Home / Library / The Tide And The Waves