Mulingai Podcast
This episode makes the strongest case for an age limit on social media, then the strongest case against one. The host argues that the design of the apps does the harm more than the age of the user, and lands on a floor of around fifteen, no ID database to enforce it, and no algorithmic feed for young users.
Welcome. Good to have you here.
Today's question is simple to ask and hard to answer.
Should kids have an age limit on social media?
I am going to do this in a particular way. First I will make the best case for yes. A real case. Not a weak one I can knock over. Then I will make the best case for no. Also a real one. And only then will I tell you where I actually land.
If I change your mind, good. If you change mine, even better.
Almost every parent I know has this argument.
Sometimes with the school. Sometimes with each other. Mostly with their own kid.
And it is never really about the phone. It is about something harder.
At what age do you let someone into a place that was not built for them?
That is the real question.
I want to say one thing early, so you know where I stand.
I am not anti-technology. I build it. I spend my days making software. So this is not "screens are bad, go outside".
I like what technology does when it opens a door for someone. I do not like what it does when it takes something from them and gives nothing back.
That is the line I am trying to find today.
The case for yes
Let me build the strongest case for a limit.
First. These apps were not made for children.
They were designed by adults. Tested on adults. Built to hold an adult's attention.
Then children walked in. Nobody designed the room for them. They just got in.
Second. The apps are built to keep you there.
That is not an accident. That is the job. Very smart people are paid very well to make it hard for you to put the phone down.
Now put a twelve year old against that. It is not a fair fight. It is not close to a fair fight.
Third. Comparison hits children harder.
Adults compare too. We all do. But an adult has a bit of armour. You have been through some things. You know most of what you see is edited.
At thirteen you do not have that yet. You are still working out who you are. And you are doing it while a thousand strangers show you a better version of your life.
Fourth. It follows them home.
When I was young, if something bad happened at school, it stopped at the school gate. You went home. You got a break.
Now there is no gate. It comes into the bedroom. It is there at eleven at night.
Fifth. Sleep.
This one is boring and it matters more than the rest. A tired child struggles with everything. Learning, mood, friendships, all of it. The phone at night takes the sleep.
Sixth. Parents cannot win this alone.
You can take your child's phone away. You cannot take away the class group chat. You cannot take away the fact that everyone else is on it.
So the parent who says no is not protecting their child from an app. They are cutting their child out of the room. That is a horrible position to put a parent in.
A rule for everyone takes that weight off one family.
And here is the part that is hard to argue with.
We already do this everywhere else. There is an age for driving. An age for alcohol. An age for voting. An age for working.
We do not think those are strange. We think they are normal.
So why is this one different?
The case for no
Now the other side. Properly.
First. How do you actually check the age?
This is the question nobody wants to answer.
To stop children, you have to check everyone. Every single user has to prove how old they are.
That means your ID. Or your face scanned. Or your passport, handed to a company you do not know.
So to protect children, every adult gives up being anonymous.
That is a very big price. And we would be paying it forever.
Second. Kids get around it. They always have.
Children have got past age rules for as long as age rules have existed. A birth year is a box you type in.
So we might build something huge, take everyone's privacy, and the determined thirteen year old is still there by Tuesday.
Third. You push them somewhere worse.
If you lock them out of the big places, they do not stop. They move.
They go to the smaller apps. The ones with no moderation. The ones nobody is watching.
You have not removed the risk. You have moved it into the dark.
Fourth. You take away real good things.
This is the one people skip, and it is important.
Think about the teenager who is the only one like them in their whole town. The one who is different in some way. The one who is struggling and cannot say it out loud at home.
For some of those kids, finding people online was the thing that helped.
Not entertainment. Help.
A limit takes that away too. It does not only remove the bad. It removes all of it.
Fifth, and this is the strongest one.
The problem is not the age. It is the design.
We are arguing about the birthday when the thing doing the harm is how the app is built.
The endless scroll. The feed that learns what upsets you and gives you more. The counters. The streaks. The notifications at midnight.
You could put the limit at eighteen and the design would still be doing that to everyone above it.
Sixth. A limit lets the companies off the hook.
This is the part that bothers me most.
If we pass an age law, the company gets to say: we checked the age. We followed the rule.
And now the failure belongs to the parent who did not stop their kid lying about a birth year.
We would have moved the blame from the people who designed it to the people trying to survive it.
Where I land
Here is where I actually land. You can disagree with me. I hope some of you do.
I think the age limit is the wrong fight. But I still want one.
Let me explain that, because it sounds like I am dodging.
The wrong fight is this: if we spend the next five years arguing about whether it is thirteen or fifteen or sixteen, we will have spent five years arguing about a number while nothing about the product changes.
The number is not what is hurting anyone. The design is.
So if I could only choose one thing, I would not choose an age. I would choose this.
For young users, no algorithmic feed. Show them the people they actually followed. In order. That is it.
No engine deciding what will keep them scrolling tonight.
That single change would do more than any birth year box ever will.
And I would put the work on the company, not the child. Not "did the user lie". "Did you build something safe for the people you knew were there."
Because they do know. They have always known.
But I said I still want a limit, so let me be honest about why.
Two reasons.
One. It buys time. Not because the rule is perfect. Because it gives a parent something to stand on. Right now a parent says no and they are alone. With a rule, they are not the only one saying it. That is worth something real.
Two. It says out loud that this is not normal. Sometimes a society needs to name a thing. A limit is us saying: we noticed. This was not fine.
So where do I land?
Yes to a floor. Around fifteen, if you make me pick a number. No to putting everyone's ID into a database to enforce it. And the real work is the design, not the birthday.
If we only get the age limit, we will have done the easy thing and told ourselves we solved it.
Over to you
Now it is your turn.
Some questions, pick whichever one you have an opinion about.
If there was a limit, what age would you pick? And be honest about why that number.
Parents: what did you actually do? Not what you think you should have done. What you did.
Would you hand over your ID to a company if it meant children were kept out?
And the one I am most curious about. If you could change one thing about how these apps work, and you could not change the age at all, what would you change?
That is the episode.
Thank you for spending this time with me.
One last thing, and then I will stop.
The reason I care about this question is the same reason I do the work I do.
I spend my days trying to open a door so that more people can be part of something.
Technology is very good at opening a door. It is also very good at closing one and charging you to watch.
The whole job is telling those two apart.
Thank you. Good night.