Hugh Black
Hugh Black preaches on the story of Balaam, whom God first forbade to go with Balak's messengers, then allowed to go, and was angry because he went. He shows that Balaam's heart was already set on the reward, that God permits what He does not sanction because He will not force the human will, and that the guilt of sin begins in desire. The only safety is a will freely given to God.
And God said unto Balaam, Thou shalt not go with them.... And God came unto Balaam at night and said unto him, If the men come to call thee, rise up and go with them.... And God's anger was kindled because he went.—Numbers xxii. 12, 20-22.
I do not propose at this time to enter into a consideration of the complex character of Balaam as related in this story, except in so far as it may illustrate the subject suggested by our text. These words we have chosen touch some of the deepest problems of life and religion, the problems that circle round the subject of the place and freedom of the human will. I wish to treat it as little philosophically as possible, and as practically and ethically as I can. It is not necessary to enlarge much on the setting of our text. The situation of Balaam at this point of the narrative is a common one, allowing for the differences of time and custom and the accidentals of life. It is simply the situation of a man keenly desirous of doing something which he knows to be wrong, and who seeks to reconcile a real conscientiousness with his desire.
Balak offers him things which his heart covets, if he will go to him and curse for him the Israelites. Balaam is persuaded in his own mind that he cannot do this as things stand, that it will be contrary to the will of God who has blessed Israel; and yet he would fain earn the reward in some way without being absolutely false. He would not accept once for all the plain intimation of God's will and the simple acceptance of duty; but at the same time he is determined not to disobey the dictates of conscience. This at least is his attitude to begin with. When Balak's messengers came with the bribes and promises, he held firm to what he believed to be God's will, and came out of the shock of the first temptation unharmed. ‘God said unto Balaam, Thou shalt not go with them. And Balaam rose up in the morning and said unto the princes of Balak, Get ye into your own land: for the Lord refuseth to give me leave to go with you.’ He had no doubt in his mind as to what God's will was in the matter, and he stated that unflinchingly in spite of the fact that he fain would have gone; and if nothing further had occurred, it would all have looked like a moral victory for Balaam; and indeed, so it...
But it is not the way of temptation to come once and be content with a single repulse. On Balaam's refusal a still more imposing embassy was sent with more lavish promises of reward. If the former occasion had represented a complete moral victory, this would not have been much of a temptation. The prophet could only have repeated his refusal. He had learned what his duty was. But, enticed by the promised bribes, he cast about for some way of getting what his heart was set on. He thought he might possibly obtain leave to do what God had before forbidden. Instead of sending the envoys away, he bade them wait in the hope that he might be able to get a more favourable answer. He seemed to succeed; for he did receive permission to go. ‘God said unto him, If the men come to call thee, rise up and go with them.’ Nothing was really altered. He knew he was not allowed to curse instead of bless. But he still hoped that some further concession might be granted which would enable him to earn the reward. He was only entering into temptation, getting nearer to it, playing with it, going with open eyes into a situation which would inevitably make it more difficult for him to be true. The...
This is no character-sketch of Balaam; or there would here lie on the very surface for us many lessons of warning and counsel, warnings about the beginning of evil and the genesis of sin in the mind, and dallying with temptation. I prefer just now to touch a deeper thought suggested by the words of our text, with their startling contrast, ‘God said unto Balaam, Go.... And God's anger was kindled because he went.’ Subtle and complex as Balaam's character may have been, it contains no such strange and dark mystery as the mystery of God's providence shadowed forth in these astounding words. At first it seems a mistake, an impossible reading of events. What tragedy and what mystery underlie these sentences, ‘God said unto Balaam, Thou shalt not go with them.’ And then because Balaam wanted it, longed for it, set his heart on it, ‘God said unto him, Go.’ And all the time he was going to his own hurt, compassing his life about with many evils. ‘God's anger was kindled against him because he went.’ The paradox of Balaam's character, great as it is, is nothing to the appalling paradox that God should permit what is against His will—that a man should receive a permission which was not a...
Yet is not this the common situation of us all? Is this not the invariable environment of all moral life, that we are allowed to enter into temptation, allowed to go against the very will of God? That this should be so, that man should possess such terrible power, seems the great mystery of our life; and yet it cannot be otherwise if we are to remain men. It is no isolated instance, this case of Balaam's. Right through the Bible we find the same explanation of this weird power of man to go against God and to get his way against God to his own undoing; as when Israel desired a king, in order to be like other nations, rather than be a theocracy in which they had no king but God, it is stated that God gave them a king in His anger; or the Psalmist's explanation of the fatal time in the desert, when the Israelites lusted after the flesh-pots of Egypt and despised the manna; and when the flesh-meat came it brought with it a terrible plague from which many died. The Psalmist points the same moral, ‘They lusted exceedingly in the wilderness and tempted God in the desert. And He gave them their request; but sent leanness into their soul.’
It represents a fact of moral life. Permission which implied no sanction, nay, which carried with it inevitable danger! We sometimes ask why it should be so, and wonder if it might not have been otherwise. Is it necessary that we should have to run such risks and undergo such menace? If God's anger is to be kindled against Balaam if he went, why ever permit him to go? If to agree to the Israelites’ request means to send leanness into their souls, why ever give them their request? This is the great mystery of sin, and the great mystery (of which it is a part) of man's free will, which means freedom to do wrong as well as to do right, freedom to sin, freedom to go against the law of our own being and against the law of God and the will of God. In this respect God cannot keep from us what we want. God does not—cannot—violate man's will, compelling him as by physical necessity to do right. It would cease to be a moral world, and we would cease to be men in the sense we are. Only moral means can be used to achieve a moral end. Thus the place of a man in the spiritual kingdom is settled not by his gifts, or attainments, or capacities, or actions even, but by his will. When Balaam...
For, notice further, that from the point of view of pure morality the evil was done. The birth of sin is not in the sinful act, but in the sinful desire. Lady Macbeth's argument to her husband, after he had planned the murder of Duncan, and then wavered—not because he repented, but partly for reasons of fear, and partly for reasons of policy—is a cogent argument from the purely moral point of view. Her argument is that he was guilty of the crime already, since it was still in his heart.
Art thou afeard To be the same in thine own act and valour, As thou art in desire? Wouldst thou have that Which thou esteem'st the ornament of life, And live a coward in thine own esteem; Letting I dare not wait upon I would, Like the poor cat i’ the adage?
Not that a man who thinks evil may as well go on to commit the evil, though that is the devil's argument which comes to many a man, and which Lady Macbeth made use of in the passage quoted; but that the first guilt of sin does lie in the evil will; and an evil will only needs opportunity in order to blossom out into the full-blown crime, or vice, or cruelty or shame. Balaam had disobeyed God in his heart before he set out for Balak's court. He was not really a worse man through the permission to go. Indeed, it was perhaps the only chance for him to become a better man by being compelled to realise that he was offending God. This permission to go was only the natural and even the inevitable result of the kindling passion in his heart.
What we lust after, what we give our heart to, what we really request from God and from man, what we desire as our chief good and foster in our thoughts as the imperious need of our lives, that we cannot but get. Though it be tempting God as the Israelites did, God will give us our request, though it means sending leanness into our soul. When we make our deliberate, conscious persistent choice, the mere practical form it takes is a detail. If our mind is ever turning towards some darling sin, as Balaam lusted after the reward, how can we, in a world like this, which is built on moral principles, be prevented from carrying our desire into action? We cannot will the evil, and be saved from all the consequences and the fruits of evil. The sin of the heart only lacks an opportunity to be turned into conduct; and God cannot keep the opportunity from us for ever. The evil is already done, when the heart is wholly given up to it. Sooner or later we have our way. We persist: we tempt God for it: we desire it: we seek it: we will have it and must have it—take it, the sin and its sting, ‘Go.... And God's anger was kindled because he went.’
Safety is to be found alone in the sphere wherein lies the danger, in the will. Even from the most sinful life and surroundings there is ever a point of departure for each of us in the will. The free will of man is at last justified, and only then, when it is freely given to God. If sin finds its hold and seat there, so also does salvation. We always come back to heart-religion; for nothing else is of any avail. No outside prevention, no careful cleansing of the outside of cup and platter is of use. Even if Balaam had not gone and yet had his heart full of covetousness, the mere abstention was nothing. Balaam is only safe when he does not even want to go since it is against God's will. He is only safe if he would not go though he could, since he knows it is contrary to the will of God. Only that will is safe, which is conformed to the will of God, which really seeks to do the will of God, which is guarded and inspired, at once protected and driven, by the will of God. Only that heart is safe which is fixed upon God. The ideal for man is a holy will which voluntarily chooses the good, which says, ‘Lo, I come to do Thy will, O God.’ If we make God's will our will, His way shall be...