Hugh Black
Hugh Black preaches on Paul's charge, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think, but to think soberly. He shows that the church is one body bound together by mutual service, warns against both the false humility that shrinks from service and the conceit that spoils it, and describes true humility as a sober valuation of the gifts God has given. In God's presence we are first humbled, then raised to our feet to serve.
For I say, through the grace given unto me, to every man that is among you, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think; but to think soberly, according as God hath dealt to every man the measure of faith.—Romans xii. 3.
After the dogmatic statement of Christian truth, contained in the first part of this great Epistle, with its keen logic and wealth of historical illustration, St. Paul proceeds to give the practical conclusions which follow to the Christian community. He shows how the faith which he has built up in reasoned steps carries an implication, on their part, who hold the faith, to live it out in conduct. St. Paul never elaborates the doctrinal side of religion for its own sake. The doctrinal exists for the sake of the ethical. The two are ever interwoven into the fabric of his thought. Christian conduct, Christian duty, Christian character, flow from Christian doctrine, as a stream from its fountain. Having shown the depths of the riches of the wisdom and the knowledge of God in the scheme of Christian truth, he drives home the conclusion that complete self-surrender to God is reasonable service. The purpose of it all in the mind of God, and therefore the aim that men are called on to set before them, is a transformed life, a renewed mind, a proving in practice of the perfect will of God.
St. Paul begins with the fact of the existing Church, and the duties which rest upon all members of the Church. The keynote of the whole is mutual service. All organisation, all individual gifts of teaching, exhorting, liberality, must be subservient to this great end. So the first emphasis is laid on personal humility and modesty. Because the Church is one body of which we each are members, because the Church exists for the good of the whole, there is no room for self-exaltation. St. Paul is himself here an example of humility in the very way he recommends the duty. He presumes to advise ‘through the grace given unto me’—not of his own wisdom or goodness. The sweet humble way in which St. Paul advises is the strongest argument of his sermon. The Christian is not to be haughty, and lofty-minded, but to think soberly of himself with insight into his place in the body of Christ, with wise discretion, not asserting himself, considering in all things the edification of all. This is essential for the sake of peace in the Church, for the sake of order and good government. The Christian must not be self-pushing, but should measure his gifts and opportunities of service, ever subserving...
The value of a gift is its social value. This is why St. Paul insists so much in all his Epistles on humility when he refers to the function of the Church. Without it the Church cannot do her work. This is why St. Paul says in this very letter, ‘Be not high-minded, but fear’ and ‘Be not wise in your own conceits’; and here, ‘I say,’ a solemn declaration as the word implies, ‘I say unto every man among you, not to think of himself more highly than he ought to think; but to think soberly, according as God hath dealt to every man the measure of faith.’ There is here the true middle course between the extremes of false self-esteem and false humility. His purpose is to encourage them to service, to cultivate their gifts. Thus, he does not set before them as an ideal any kind of self-abnegation which would mean the withdrawal of any from service. That on the one hand. And on the other hand, in order to make that service really effective it is necessary to purge it from self-exaltation. They are to measure themselves in all sobriety of judgment, that without presumption, and yet, without shrinking, they may put all their gifts at the service of the Church.
This touches on one of the greatest difficulties of life in every sphere, as well as in the religious. From the failures on both sides of the golden mean, we see how difficult it is for men to get a just and true estimate of self. It is not easy to steer a straight course, to avoid Scylla on the one side, and Charybdis on the other, to avoid being driven on the rocks by undue self-trust, and avoid being sucked into the whirlpool by undue self-mistrust. For true balance of character and to produce the best work in any line, it is necessary for a man to have both humility, and also self-confidence. There is a false humility, which weakens a man and unfits him for the duties of life. It is often indistinguishable from moral cowardice, a refusal to put forth the best powers, a slackness of moral tissue which may be as fatal a form of self-indulgence as any other form of it. Some escape the snares of ambition and worldliness by falling willingly into meaner snares. If ambition is an infirmity, it at least often submits to scorn delights and live laborious days. If vainglory will make a man think too highly of himself; so this cowardice will make him think so meanly of himself that he...
As there is a false humility which spoils character and work, so there is an over-weening conceit which is equally weak and which keeps a man from his true place of usefulness. An exaggerated sense of personal importance, an inordinate ambition for the first places, an egotism which judges of everything according as it affects that sweet gentleman self, a self-pushing, self-advertising spirit which will not enter into anything unless self is to be the first dog in the hunt—that is the other extreme against which St. Paul warns the Roman Christians. We see it in life in all quarters, marring harmony among brethren, preventing successful co-operation in good, a source of strife and failure, hindering progress in every branch. We see it in Church and State, in the family and the civic life, in business and play. Even a football team cannot win a match because single members think so highly of themselves, and aim at personal glory instead of the success of the side. We hear it said of a strong man in politics, in business, in religion, even in the Christian Ministry, that he will not work alongside of others, that he is too self-opinionative, that indeed nobody can work with him,...
Now, it is no easy task to which St. Paul sets us not to think more highly of ourselves than we ought to think. For it is difficult to convince us that we do think more of self than we ought. To himself each man is the universe. A man knows his own needs and wishes better than he can know those of others. His own inclinations make imperious demands on him. It is easy to become self-centred; for nobody is so important to you as you yourself.
The difficulty is increased if, as we have seen, it is at the same time essential not to minimise and undervalue any gift a man has. We can see this difficulty in every sphere of human life. Take art for example. It is necessary for an artist to know his limitations, and to submit to them. If he thinks he has reached the summit of his art and is filled with self-complacency, his work becomes weak and worthless. Without humility he can never rise above the commonplace. Here, as elsewhere in all human endeavours, it is only the meek who inherit the kingdom. Yet much feebleness in art and tiresome repetition are due to lack of courage, to a false humility, a base content with the small. This is only an illustration of our text that both modesty and confidence are needed.
St. Paul's whole argument in this passage is that God has given to men certain gifts, different in kind and in degree; and it is essential for each to know these with accuracy, and to judge of them with sobriety, that we may use them effectively. Humility is thus not an ignorance, real or affected, of what our gifts are, but a proper valuation of them. Vanity comes from a false estimate. Think what it would mean for the Church as an associated endeavour after the Christian life, if every member looked on this subject sacredly, as St. Paul asks. If none shirked responsibility; if none avoided work through weakness, and none assumed it through conceit; if all thought of mutual service, what diligence would be put into our ministering, what patience into our teaching, what liberality into our giving, what fervency into our prayers, what love into our service! If we only thought of the complete good of Christ's body the Church, and Christ's strayed sheep in the wilderness, how we would comfort and strengthen each other; and look for open doors for well-doing! The sobriety of judgment about self which St. Paul recommends would induce humility; and humility would make the whole social...
Candid and courageous self-examination would for one thing kill censoriousness, the canker of so many Christian characters. An enlightened man, who has looked at himself steadily, is more concerned about his own faults than about the faults of others, of which he has less knowledge. Censoriousness is fed by vanity. The social relations which begin with, ‘conscious as we are of each other's infirmities,’ are sure to be strained relations. Vanity gets rid of the thought of personal weakness by magnifying the faults of others; and that is why censoriousness can only be cured by adopting St. Paul's method of self-examination. Humility is a thing of the spirit, and cannot be put on like a cloak. A man does not become humble by simulating the form of it, by any outside method of repression, such as refusing to speak about himself, or by speaking about the bad in him. Self-condemnation is often only a subtler vanity. It may even be that a man is thinking more highly of himself than he ought to think, when he imagines that his importance is such that he may indulge in the luxury of confession. Poor weak human nature can enjoy itself immensely with making confession, as many criminals used...
How are we to attain to the balance of character, which will be both humble and strong, which will avoid both self-exaltation and self-abnegation? ‘Lead me to the Rock that is higher than I.’ We need to have hearts and life submitted to the searching light, which, while it reveals all flaws, yet inspires with hope. The first vision of Christ seems given for our despair; and then He becomes our inspiration. This seems an impossible combination of ideas; and yet it is natural. When a man comes into the presence of God, the first effect seems blighting, and withering. He can only be to himself a poor worm of the dust, and realise for the first time the absolute nothingness of the human. He is emptied of all pretensions, in complete effacement of self. The trembling question is, ‘What is man and the son of man?’ Nothing great is possible to the man who has not been thus emptied of self, beat down, and broken, lying helpless at the feet of God.
But it does not end there. There comes a strange revulsion of feeling, and the dawning of a new hope. The thought creeps in that it is possible for man to have relations with the eternal, that God does visit him, and does remember him; till the thought becomes a word of encouragement and command, ‘Son of man, stand upon thy feet, and I will speak unto thee.’ This inspiring consciousness of communion with God strengthens, as well as humbles.
It is a new stream of vitality flooding every vein, and bathing every nerve. And the man rises, never again to think presumptuously, not to think more highly of himself than he ought; and yet stronger in the knowledge that God thinks him worthy to be His and to serve Him. True self-surrender to God takes away self-exaltation, and at the same time saves from despair; for it shows a man that God has a place for him in His purpose of love, and crowns him with the nobility of service. This is the secret of St. Paul's declaration through the grace given unto him, to every man among us, not to think more highly of ourselves than we ought, but to think soberly, according as God has given to each the measure of faith.