Confession and Forgiveness

Phillips Brooks

Brooks preaches on David's confession, I have sinned against the Lord, and Nathan's reply, The Lord also hath put away thy sin. Using selfishness as his example, he describes the four parts of a full confession: seeing the acts, owning their wrong, owning that they are against God, and tracing them to a sinful heart. He declares that full forgiveness follows a full confession at once, resting on God's promise, and urges his hearers not to let Lent pass without it.

"And David said unto Nathan, I have sinned against the Lord. And Nathan said unto David, The Lord also hath put away thy sin; thou shalt not die."—2 Sam. xii. 13.

Here is the story of a confession and a forgiveness, told with a compactness that almost startles us, the two are crowded so closely together. King David, after his great sin against Uriah, had hardly been brought to own his guilt, had hardly got the words of confession off his lips, before the prophet, who represented before him the justice and authority of God, gave back the answer as if he had it all ready upon his lips and had been waiting for the chance to give it. "I have sinned against the Lord." "The Lord also hath put away thy sin."

We talk so much about confession and forgiveness; we elaborate their theory so much; we see such intricate relations of the divine and human natures involved in the transaction, that we almost unconsciously transfer the long train of thought into a long period of time. We feel as if that result which implies so much spiritual action must be reached only by a process of correspondingly prolonged duration. "To confess and be forgiven—that is the work of months and years, of a whole lifetime," we declare. And then comes in this simple story of how the whole was but the transaction of a moment with David—of how one minute he was standing obstinate and rebellious, stout in his sin, and the next minute the whole change had come and the hard heart was softened and the proud will had bent and the sin was gone. All this comes in to remind us that the most intricate moral processes take but a moment to result. The volcano that the chemistry of years has been preparing breaks into eruption in an hour. The blossom that the patient plant has been designing for a century bursts into flower in a single night. And so the reconciliation of a soul to God, which it has been the labor of the ages to...

To-day I wish to speak to you of the true nature of the confession and forgiveness of sin. But since we must find on unfolding it that the whole process is made up of many parts, and so may get this wrong idea about the time it requires, I would guard myself at the outset by this story. The whole is but a moment's work. Men, making their systems, cast out the notion of an instantaneous conversion. If conversion means turning from bad to good, from self to God, lo, here is certainly an instantaneous conversion. Because the quick chemistries of grace take our slow study a lifetime—nay, an eternity—to understand, let us not forget that it takes God but a moment to work their beautiful combinations and create the strange new life whose power is folded up within them. I say it boldly and fully: you may be converted now and here, as you sit in church. Here and now you may confess your sins and be forgiven and start a better life. Oh, if God would only grant that you might! It did not take David any longer. At least keep in mind that it is possible while I try to explain to you in full what the true nature of confession is.

What is it to confess one's sin? I think that the complete act includes four parts, all of which are necessary, the absence of any one of which makes the act incomplete. In order to make the matter plainer let us talk, not about sin in general, but about some special sin—say the sin of selfishness. I select this sin for several reasons: first, because it is the commonest sin in lives not openly vicious; second, because it is the one least easily detected and confessed; and third, because in its large scope it includes and embraces every other sin. What is necessary, then, for a selfish man really and truly to confess his selfishness?

1. To own that he has done selfish things. That is the first step to be taken. That is the first struggle. To get at the plain facts; to set out in their array the long line of acts that have not been done from any higher motive than the mere desire for one's own personal comfort or advantage. Even this is not easy. The acts know their own guiltiness and flee behind all kinds of shelter to escape scrutiny; and the man who is really bent upon discovering and confessing them has to seize hold of their reluctance with a strong hand and force them out. Are you bent on finding your own selfishness? First of all, you must not let the occasional unselfish things that you have done, the few brilliant days when you can recall some generous deed of self-sacrifice—you must not let the luster of such rare exceptions, all the more lustrous from their very rareness, hide from your view the constant tenor of your living, which has been made up of things in which your neighbor's good has had no share of influence. And then you must not let yourself be blinded by the specious sophistry which tells you that these selfish acts of yours were not entirely selfish, because in some remote effect of them...

2. Another struggle will come as a man passes on to the second stage, which is the full acknowledgment of the true moral character of such a life. Once convinced that he is selfish, a soul, with more or less consciousness of the sophistry that it is using, almost always sets to work to feel that selfishness is not wrong, but right. "Very well," it says, "I am selfish, I do live for myself; but what then? Whom should I live for? Is not my own interest and good my first care? Who will take care of me if I do not take care of myself? Must not charity begin at home? Is not this the way the world is meant to work, that every man should nurse his own interests, and so, by the development of each, they all should grow? Is not mankind meant to rise to its perfection as a flock of birds rises, each pair of hurrying wings moved by its own fear of danger or hope of gain, without consideration of the others, the result being that the whole solid flock rises together and moves like one great cloud of the sky? Is it not best that each should care for himself? And so, selfish as I am, is not my selfishness a virtue, instead of a sin?" Unstated, vaguely felt, this is the acted theory of...

3. Then the selfish man passes on to the third step of his confession, which is the acknowledgment that the sin he has committed is an offense against God. Here is the first place where religion necessarily begins. All up to this point may be wholly unreligious. But the confession must be made to some one. What is the authority which has been violated by these acts of yours, which you have decided against as being selfish? Is it just the natural authority of the rights of your fellowmen—some human claim which they have upon your sympathy and help? I think not. I do not see that it is possible to show that, besides the right that every man has not to be injured by his neighbors, there is another claim by which he can complain if his neighbors do not go out of their way to help him. Is it, then, some abstract law or principle of the mutual harmonies of universal life against which the selfish man sins, to which he must confess? Surely no obedience to such an abstraction—which, after all, is only a generalization, an induction of the man's own mind—can bind a man's hot passions from their self-indulgence, or bend his proud head in penitent confession of wrong-doing. What then? The...

No one knows till he has really thus confessed how great the relief is of a recognition of this sole responsibility to God. We mount above our fellow-men and their judgment-seats. We leave their puny criticisms far below us. They may be right in blaming us—no doubt they are. But past their blame the very magnitude of our guilt exalts us to a higher judgment-seat. The soul, full of God's power and love at once, is not satisfied to utter itself to less than Him. It must cry as David did in that Fifty-first Psalm, which he wrote about this same crime touching Uriah: "Against Thee, Thee only, have I sinned, and done this evil in Thy sight." In one word, it must be able to complete the whole confession of our text, and say, not merely, "I have sinned," but "I have sinned against the Lord."

4. And what more is there in the true confession of selfishness? Only one thing, I think, and that is the acknowledgment that the selfish acts which we confess are representations and expressions of a selfish character and heart in which our true guilt abides. If you could make out an absolutely complete list of all the selfish acts that you have ever done, all the selfish words that you have ever spoken, all the selfish thoughts that you have ever thought, and bringing it up, should unroll it in the sight of God, and, pointing with shame down the long catalogue, should say, "Look, Lord, and read. They are all there. I have not left out one. The black tale is complete"—when that is over, have you confessed your selfishness? You have not touched it. As fertile and as foul as ever, it lies deep in your heart, ready to breed new selfish acts when these are cleared away. Not till you trace these things down to their roots; not till you say, "I did wrong things because I was a wrong thing. I lived for myself, not for my neighbors, because I loved myself a great deal better than my neighbors, and so broke God's law in my heart before I broke it with my hands. I was, I am, a living...

How feebly we talk and think about the judgment-day! We tremble when we picture God upon His great white throne, hurling at our dismayed terror the long succession of our sins. We shudder at the thought of this deed and of that deed which we must meet again. The true horror of the judgment-day will be the making manifest of hearts. What I have done will fade before the preeminent shame at what I have been. Then, if not before, deeds will take their true places as mere fruits and types of characters. Just as we grow into the solemnity of the judgment-day we attain its point of view already, and learn to enlarge David's "I have sinned" into Simon Peter's "I am a sinful man, O Lord." Then, as we said, the confession is complete.

Taking a single sin, then—selfishness—I have tried to show you how, in the heart of a man who is really trying to confess his wickedness, the confession gradually grows to fullness. First there is the seeing of the fact, then the acknowledgment of the moral character of the fact, then the owning of responsibility to God for the wrong-doing, and last the consciousness that the wrong-doing is a wrong-being, that the sins are sinfulness. It may come upon a man all in a flash, as it did on David; or it may grow hardly, fought against stoutly, conquering step by step for itself, taking years, perhaps, to get entire possession of the nature. But it must come, and it must all come, or the man's sins are not genuinely confessed. When it has all come, a man need not question how it came—slowly or swiftly, calmly or violently; however it came, the confession is perfect, and in the utterness of his humiliation there is nothing more that he can do.

And what comes then? Ah, here we come to the better news, the glad tidings, the "Gospel" of our sermon. "I have sinned against the Lord." And Nathan answered, "The Lord also hath put away thy sin." Quickly as all God's laws fulfil themselves, quick as the rain-drops catch the sunlight and the rainbow springs to sight, quick as the hillside hears the thunder and answers with its echo, so quick—immediately—the whole forgiveness follows on the whole confession. We need to know how absolute this is. I want to state it in its fullness and invariableness. There is a law in our natures that makes it necessarily certain that if you touch a particular muscle the arm will quiver; if you appeal to a particular feeling the anger will rise and flush the face. Now just so it is a law of God's nature—invariable with a godlike uniformity, more certain than the succession of the seasons or the comings and the goings of the stars—that if a human being touches Him with a true confession He must answer with an unreserved forgiveness.

Notice, my friends, who think to try, this Lent, perhaps to-day, this great experiment: it must be the complete confession that we have been describing. No element of all the four must be left out. It must have all the honesty and profoundness of the total act. No flippant temporary sorrow, no moment's gust of wild regret, will answer. But to the patient, steady, whole-souled faith of the entire confession the attempt is no experiment. It must succeed. It has succeeded as soon as it is made. "The sin is put away" the very moment that the heart has dropped its burden by the cross: "I have sinned against the Lord."

"Are you not stating this too blankly?" some cautious guardian of the Gospel asks. "Is there not something more needed before the perfect forgiveness, the entire reconciliation, can be thus assumed? Will not your words make men presumptuous unless you add something else?" What shall it be, then? I confess I do not know. Jesus says, "Ask, and ye shall receive; seek, and ye shall find." Shall we say that a man must be sorry for his sin and leave it before he can be forgiven? Certainly he must; but that act of converted resolution is included, I hold, in the confession that I have described. If David meant just to go on in sinning—killing new Uriahs and taking their wives—Nathan surely would never have accepted his confession. The prophet evidently felt that it included the determination of a better life. But shall we say that this better life must be begun, that some good steps in it must be taken to prove its reality, before a man ought to count himself forgiven? That is not so, for the true ground whereon I trust I am forgiven is not the symptoms that I see in myself. That would make very poor business of my faith and peace. It is the simple belief in the promises of God. And...

Yes, there is danger lest we guard the Gospel overmuch. There is danger lest the walls we build to keep the truth in keep the souls of men out. Let us not be afraid to be as free as Christ. A whole confession must bring a true forgiveness. If we confess our sins, He is faithful and just to forgive us. The moment you cry, "God be merciful to me a sinner," the reply is ready: "Thy faith hath saved thee; go in peace."

My friends, our Lent is here. There is no magic in its days. It is only that we have resolved till Easter to give more time and thought to our religious life. All that may come to much or it may come to nothing. I beg you, let it come to much. And the way to do that is to bring your soul up to the point of whole and genuine confession. By any discontent you have now with your life, by any longing for a better heart, by the solemn responsibility you owe to God, by the great unutterable love of Christ, I beg you, as if I went from ear to ear and pleaded with each of you, not to let this Lent pass without confessing your sinfulness and being forgiven and becoming a grateful servant of Jesus Christ. May God grant it for all.

Home / Library / Confession And Forgiveness