John Watson (Ian Maclaren)
John Watson preaches on Peter's words to the risen Christ, Lord, Thou knowest all things, Thou knowest that I love Thee. Peter, who had denied his Master, could only appeal to the love beneath his failure, and Jesus restored him. Watson shows that most people are a mixture of good and bad, that God judges a soul not by its outward record but by the direction of its desire, and that this judgment is both merciful and righteous, counting the effort of everyone who strives after goodness.
"And Simon Peter said unto Jesus, 'Lord, Thou knowest all things, Thou knowest that I love Thee.' Jesus said unto him, 'Feed My sheep.'"—St. John xxi. 17.
When St. Peter, wrought into a mixed agony of love and penitence, made this daring appeal to the omniscience of the Lord, and obtained a decision, his case settled the basis of the Divine judgment upon character. It was one in which the average man with his rough and ready rules would have certainly blundered, and in which even persons of insight might have been perplexed. St. Peter was a friend of Jesus and had boasted loudly of loyalty; yet he had not only forsaken his Master with the rest, but had openly denied Him. He was a chosen apostle and set forth to be an example of holiness; yet he had confirmed his denial with swearing. Certainly he had received no money for his desertion; but otherwise, was there much difference between Iscariot and Simon? Both were false, and Peter had made the louder profession and had held the more prominent place. He might say that he was still a true man and a lover of Jesus, but he could not reasonably expect a favourable verdict from any jury of his fellow men. If denying your friend with an oath in the black straits of life be affection, let us rather have a man's hatred. Facts are facts, his human judges would conclude, for this man to meet...
St. Peter had himself realized the hopelessness of the situation, and until Jesus sought him out he had been ashamed to meet with his fellow apostles. They could only have one mind of him, that he was a traitor, and yet he knew that while he was everything else that was bad, a boaster, a coward, a swearer, he was not a traitor. But to prove this was impossible. Against his protestation could be set his action, and men would only laugh if he talked of his intention. No man can open his heart to his neighbour and show its secret bias, no man can search his own heart and understand its workings. This tortured man could hardly expect his fellows to understand him, for as he keenly remembered he had not understood himself. He was an insoluble enigma, and he had hoped that his Master would have done him justice. When Jesus seemed to repudiate his profession of love, then Peter made one last appeal. It is from his fellow men and from himself; it is even the words of Jesus to Jesus' unerring knowledge. "Lord, Thou knowest everything, all I said and all I did and all I am, but this Thou also knowest, that beneath the foul spume of my outer life, the deepest thing in my heart is love to...
With only a surface knowledge of life we come to quick and absolute judgments, and therefore one understands the prayer, "Lord, deliver me from a young judge." People are divided into two classes with a clear-cut frontier, and each class is locked into its own country. So many people are good, we say, with various enthusiastic adjectives; so many are bad with every kind of condemnation. So many we like with much warmth; so many we dislike with equal warmth. With a larger experience and a riper mind the dividing line begins to waver, and we are not so confident in either our approval or our disapproval. There may be a few saints in whom no fault can be found, and who are worthy to have walked with Christ in Galilee—we have known one or two such people. But on closer examination of the candidates for sainthood we are apt to be disillusionised, and to find that for the most part they are men of like passions with ourselves. One man comes short of perfection by his temper, another by his meanness, a third by his self-righteousness, a fourth by his vanity. Do the Gospels suggest that the apostles were faultless? Had St. Francis no failings which were concealed by his disciples? Was not...
On the other hand let us console ourselves that there are not many thoroughly wicked persons. Perhaps we have suffered at some one's hands and spoken strongly against him, but after our indignation has died down we would frankly acknowledge that there was much goodness in him. We may have censured some one for an evil deed, and next day have repented because of something kindly that he had done. If history affords few perfect saints it also does not contain many desperate sinners. Against St. John there is Alexander Borgia, against Elizabeth of Hungary there is Messalina; but those are rare extremes. Neither flawless goodness nor unredeemed wickedness is common; but it is more easy to find John than Judas.
As regards the mass of people they are neither angels nor devils. The representative man has his excellencies and his deficiencies side by side; his character alternates between light and shadow. He is capable of strong affection and vindictive hatred; he can rise to magnanimity, and he can condescend to pettiness. It depends how he is taken and how he is taking himself. To one person he is attractive, and to another he is repulsive. This is very much the condition of us all when you leave out Judas and John; we are neither black nor white, but just half and between in our spiritual character; we are "whitey-brown."
When we finally abandon the black and white theory we are apt to despair, not only of passing judgment on our fellow men, which perhaps might be an advantage, but of making any moral distinction, which would be a great disadvantage. But what are we to think? The figures are so contradictory that a balance cannot be struck. The wind blows from so many quarters that you cannot call it either East or West. The vessel tacks so much that one cannot be sure of her direction. Pass the select minority of saints and sinners, and is there really any moral difference between one man and another? Is there any ground for the clear-cut distinction made by Christ Himself? Are we divided into classes at all in this life, is there likely to be any separation in the life to come? Does character elude and defy judgment?
Certainly if one went by the evidence of life from the highway he would require not two compartments in which to arrange his fellow men, but a hundred, and he would be inclined to change his specimens from one compartment to another daily. And yet is not the soul of every man a moral unity? Are we not bound to believe that if we only had the means a man's character could be summed up? Must not every one's life yield a final result? Occasionally the real character is revealed with startling suddenness, as when a flash of lightning illuminates the darkness, and we see a landscape with ghastly clearness. The darkness falls again, but the landscape remains.
People may live together in the closest intimacy—as, for instance, in marriage—and yet never know one another. Some day, however, the inner self is declared, and the person stands forth as he is and as he is going to be.
We live together years and years, And leave unsounded still Each other's springs of hopes and fears. Each other's depths of will.
We live together day by day. And some chance look or tone Lights up with instantaneous ray An inner world, unknown.
When that happens we discover, beneath casual faults or casual virtues, the permanent trend of character. One person is loathing badness, although sometimes he is mastered by temptation, and he is loving goodness although often he fails in its attainment. Another person secretly loves what is wrong, although at times he does what is right, and seldom shows badly, although all the time his heart is bad. Life upon the surface is a contradiction because opposite currents meet, and there is a confusion of the waters; but the tide is either flowing or ebbing, and God judges not by the achievement of life, but by its tendency. It is not what a man says, nor what a man does, nor even what he is but what he desires to be, and what with his poor effort he is trying to be, which decides his moral standing. Behind words lie deeds, behind deeds qualities, behind qualities intention, and the distinction between one man and another is the innermost ambition, and the chosen attitude of the soul. The final judgment lies with God who knows all things, and who alone knows us, and God judges by the heart.
The judgment of God is full of comfort if there be in us an honest purpose of goodness. It is not easy to vindicate ourselves to men, nor even to our own conscience, for the power of the world in which we live, and the power of sin in our own hearts, are so strong that we are constantly baffled in our struggle after the best. If one should say to us, "This is what you ought to have done and you did not do it," alas! that is true. What is the good of saying in reply, we tried? What value to men or to ourselves are our tryings? They are just another word for our failings. "This is what you ought not to have done and you did it," alas! that is also true. We did resist, but we were beaten, and our very effort seems to be only another name for our sin. "What do you care for goodness?" the world says; "you, who cannot keep your temper, who are so self-willed in your actions; you, who are haunted with such unholy thoughts; you, who are so governed by the love of money?" What can a man do but plead guilty? It seems wanton audacity for him to speak of righteousness; and yet, after righteousness he is hungering and thirsting. Why, then, does he not do righteously? Wonderful insight; but...
There the tears of earth are dried. There its hidden things are clear. There the work of life is tried. By a juster judge than here.
And the finest lines which Faber wrote are these:
There is no place where earth's sorrows Are more felt than up in heaven; There is no place where earth's failings Have such kindly judgment given.
This basis of judgment is not only merciful; it is also righteous, because our success may be fortune, our intention is fact. If a man does his best to swim to the wrecked vessel with a life-line, and is thrown insensible upon the shore, who will have the heart to judge him because he has failed? Your cheap moralist talks of facts, and no doubt this is a fact that he is lying there like a helpless and useless seaweed. There are other facts which are worth mentioning; as, for instance, that he made a brave attempt, and that he only failed because the surf was too strong. We are apt to ignore such facts in our moral judgments, but they are not forgotten when God is judge. With God the effort is counted as the act, for in the spiritual world it is only a question of time, when the struggler will succeed. What one desires to be he shall be before set of sun, and the soldier who has fought bravely to the end in spite of his reverses shall be glorified. Our failures may one day count higher than our successes, and our gracious thoughts which were choked in utterance be of higher value than our finished words, when God sits on the judgment seat and weighs in His infallible scales, not...
... All the world's coarse thumb And finger failed to plumb, So passed in making up the man's account;
All instincts immature, All purposes unsure. That weighed not as his work, yet swelled the man's amount.
Thoughts hardly to be packed, Into a narrow act, Fancies that broke through language and escaped; All I could never be,
All men ignored in me, This I was worth to God, whose wheel the pitcher shaped.